In a bold and thought-provoking statement, Indian off-spinner Ravichandran Ashwin recently stirred the cricketing world by urging Chief Selector Ajit Agarkar to enforce a new standard of accountability — even for the biggest names in Indian cricket. Ashwin suggested that icons like Virat Kohli and Rohit Sharma should not be given automatic selection for major tournaments such as the World Cup, unless they participate in India A tours or similar preparatory matches.
A Call for Equal Standards
Ashwin’s comments came during a recent discussion about India’s team-building process and the pathway from domestic cricket to international selection. He emphasized that the India A program — traditionally used as a platform for emerging players — should also serve as a testing ground for established stars returning from breaks or form slumps.
According to Ashwin, selectors often face a tough balancing act between honoring seniority and maintaining meritocracy. His proposed solution? A clear, performance-based structure where every player, regardless of stature, earns their place through competitive cricket.
“If you don’t play for India A, you don’t fit into our World Cup plan,” Ashwin said, suggesting what he’d tell Agarkar if given the chance. “That rule should apply to everyone — even if it’s Virat Kohli or Rohit Sharma. Let the standard be the same for all.”
The Larger Debate: Reputation vs. Readiness
Ashwin’s remarks ignite a long-standing debate in Indian cricket — whether selection should rely on past achievements or present form. While legends like Kohli and Rohit have proven themselves repeatedly on the biggest stages, critics argue that extended breaks or lack of match practice before major tournaments can affect rhythm and team balance.
Former players and analysts have often highlighted how Australia and England manage player rotations through their domestic and A-team systems, ensuring even senior players stay game-ready before ICC events. Ashwin’s statement aligns with that philosophy, promoting a culture of consistent competition.
Agarkar’s Balancing Act
As the current Chairman of Selectors, Ajit Agarkar faces one of the toughest jobs in Indian cricket — blending experience with youth while keeping expectations sky-high. With the next major ICC event approaching, decisions regarding the inclusion of veterans and new talents will shape India’s strategy.
Ashwin’s message to Agarkar is not merely about enforcing discipline; it’s about setting a transparent selection framework. His idea pushes for a system where no player, regardless of fame, bypasses the process — thereby reinforcing accountability and fairness.
